Dataset Viewer
sample_id
stringlengths 1
115
| difficulty
stringclasses 1
value | physics_category
stringclasses 3
values | physics_law
stringclasses 8
values | edit_operation
stringclasses 16
values | edit_instruction
stringlengths 14
130
| annotated_qa_pairs
listlengths 0
12
| output_path_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
stringlengths 103
230
| output_path_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
stringlengths 104
231
| output_path_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
stringlengths 101
228
| output_path_PICABench_qwenimg
stringlengths 96
223
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
stringlengths 122
249
| output_path_PICABench_ovis_u1
stringlengths 91
111
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
stringlengths 121
248
| output_path_PICABench_flux_kontext
stringlengths 101
228
| output_path_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
stringlengths 122
249
| output_path_PICABench_hidream_e1
stringlengths 99
226
| output_path_PICABench_stepedit
stringlengths 97
224
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_think
stringlengths 100
227
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_nothink
stringlengths 102
229
| output_path_PICABench_omnigen2
stringlengths 97
224
| output_path_PICABench_uniworld
stringlengths 104
231
| output_path_PICABench_DIMOO
stringlengths 149
197
| input_image
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
imagewidth (px) 517
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
imagewidth (px) 682
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
imagewidth (px) 535
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_qwenimg
imagewidth (px) 523
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_ovis_u1
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_flux_kontext
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_hidream_e1
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_stepedit
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_think
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_nothink
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_omnigen2
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_uniworld
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_DIMOO
imagewidth (px) 352
672
| new_column
stringclasses 1
value | PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_nothink_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_flux_kontext_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_ovis_u1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_stepedit_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_qwenimg_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_DIMOO_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_uniworld_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_think_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_hidream_e1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_omnigen2_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Gemini_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Seedream_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda
|
intermediate
|
Mechanics
|
Causality
|
remove
|
Remove the 5 of spades card from the structure.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 560.9180035650623,
"width": 445.8110516934047,
"x": 0.11558792796111962,
"y": 466.24174810990223
},
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1018.9510313336491,
"width": 643.1751853303017,
"x": 0,
"y": 0
},
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0047_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0046_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0046_Delete_the_vertical_5-of-spades_card_at_the_front-left_corner_that_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image shows a playing card with the number 5 and a spade symbol on it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The image shows a playing card with the number 5 and a spade symbol on it.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The edges of the glass are parallel to the tops of the card supports and maintain consistent height relative to them; the apparent slant is due to perspective, not an actual tilt toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The edges of the glass are parallel to the tops of the card supports and maintain consistent height relative to them; the apparent slant is due to perspective, not an actual tilt toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The near-left triangular compartment is open on its side, letting you see into the interior without a card closing it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The near-left triangular compartment is open on its side, letting you see into the interior without a card closing it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left glass corner there are no cards lying flat on the floor; the visible card is leaning against the structure, so the count is zero, not one.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left glass corner there are no cards lying flat on the floor; the visible card is leaning against the structure, so the count is zero, not one.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The corner of the glass clearly contacts the tops of the card-stack supports, showing it is resting on them even while tilted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The corner of the glass clearly contacts the tops of the card-stack supports, showing it is resting on them even while tilted.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left card rests against the floor and there isn’t a distinct shadow cast directly beneath it; the floor below appears evenly lit.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left card rests against the floor and there isn’t a distinct shadow cast directly beneath it; the floor below appears evenly lit.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The card showing the number 5 with a spade symbol is clearly visible in the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The card showing the number 5 with a spade symbol is clearly visible in the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly thick, with even contact on the supports, indicating no tilt toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly thick, with even contact on the supports, indicating no tilt toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular bay is open with no card closing its face, leaving a visible gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular bay is open with no card closing its face, leaving a visible gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Beneath the front-left glass corner, all visible cards are angled as supports; none lie flat on the floor, so there isn’t exactly one.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Beneath the front-left glass corner, all visible cards are angled as supports; none lie flat on the floor, so there isn’t exactly one.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly rests on the flat tops of the card-stack supports, showing contact and support despite the tilt.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly rests on the flat tops of the card-stack supports, showing contact and support despite the tilt.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left fallen card lies flush against the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left fallen card lies flush against the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card shows a face-card illustration, not a 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card shows a face-card illustration, not a 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge appears level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge appears level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower front-left triangular cell is empty/see-through, indicating a gap without a card filling it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower front-left triangular cell is empty/see-through, indicating a gap without a card filling it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are no cards lying flat on the floor beneath that glass corner; all visible cards are part of the standing structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are no cards lying flat on the floor beneath that glass corner; all visible cards are part of the standing structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The card at the front-left lies flat on the floor, so there isn’t a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The card at the front-left lies flat on the floor, so there isn’t a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards show diamonds, clubs, and a face card; no 5 of spades is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards show diamonds, clubs, and a face card; no 5 of spades is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The apparent slant is due to perspective; the tabletop edges are parallel to the floor and uniformly supported, not dipping toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The apparent slant is due to perspective; the tabletop edges are parallel to the floor and uniformly supported, not dipping toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left lower space of the card structure has no card covering it, leaving a visible opening.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left lower space of the card structure has no card covering it, leaving a visible opening.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, the cards form slanted triangular supports; there isn’t a single card lying flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, the cards form slanted triangular supports; there isn’t a single card lying flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane is visibly supported by and in contact with the tops of the remaining card stacks, causing it to tilt after one stack collapsed.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane is visibly supported by and in contact with the tops of the remaining card stacks, causing it to tilt after one stack collapsed.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no distinct shadow on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card; the area appears uniformly lit with only very faint shading.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no distinct shadow on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card; the area appears uniformly lit with only very faint shading.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The left card clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol, indicating the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The left card clearly shows the number 5 with a spade symbol, indicating the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and to each other, with uniform thickness and consistent contact with the card supports, indicating the tabletop is level rather than slanting toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and to each other, with uniform thickness and consistent contact with the card supports, indicating the tabletop is level rather than slanting toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left triangular compartment lacks a front card, leaving a visible open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left triangular compartment lacks a front card, leaving a visible open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left glass corner there is a single flat card on the floor (the 5 of spades), with no other flat cards contiguous in that area.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left glass corner there is a single flat card on the floor (the 5 of spades), with no other flat cards contiguous in that area.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly rests on the tops of the card structures, with the tabletop’s corner supported by the stacked cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly rests on the tops of the card structures, with the tabletop’s corner supported by the stacked cards.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen front-left card rests on the floor without a distinct dark shadow directly beneath it; the floor tone remains uniform under the card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen front-left card rests on the floor without a distinct dark shadow directly beneath it; the floor tone remains uniform under the card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The large front-facing card shows five spade pips, indicating the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The large front-facing card shows five spade pips, indicating the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no glass tabletop in the image; it shows a structure made of playing cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no glass tabletop in the image; it shows a structure made of playing cards.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower front-left compartment has no card covering it, leaving an open space you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower front-left compartment has no card covering it, leaving an open space you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no glass in the image, and no playing card lying flat on the floor—only leaning cards forming a house of cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no glass in the image, and no playing card lying flat on the floor—only leaning cards forming a house of cards.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The slanted tabletop surface is visibly supported by the card stacks beneath it at its edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The slanted tabletop surface is visibly supported by the card stacks beneath it at its edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shadow is visible on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shadow is visible on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image clearly shows a playing card marked with the number 5 and spade symbols.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The image clearly shows a playing card marked with the number 5 and spade symbols.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level with consistent height above the card supports; no visual cue shows the front-left corner lower than the others.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level with consistent height above the card supports; no visual cue shows the front-left corner lower than the others.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular cell beneath the glass has no card closing it, leaving a visible open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular cell beneath the glass has no card closing it, leaving a visible open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no single card lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the cards there are angled as supports, not flat.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no single card lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the cards there are angled as supports, not flat.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly in contact with and supported by the triangular card stacks beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly in contact with and supported by the triangular card stacks beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shaded patch is visible on the floor directly under the front-left tilted card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shaded patch is visible on the floor directly under the front-left tilted card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include an Ace of Diamonds, clubs, and a face card; no 5 of Spades is shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include an Ace of Diamonds, clubs, and a face card; no 5 of Spades is shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level and parallel with the floor and supports, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level and parallel with the floor and supports, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left compartment lacks a front card, leaving the triangular bay open and visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left compartment lacks a front card, leaving the triangular bay open and visible.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a single white card panel lying flat on the floor under that glass corner; the other cards nearby are angled or vertical.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There is a single white card panel lying flat on the floor under that glass corner; the other cards nearby are angled or vertical.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass sheet is supported by multiple house-of-cards stacks beneath it, visibly touching their top edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass sheet is supported by multiple house-of-cards stacks beneath it, visibly touching their top edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A faint dark area is visible on the floor directly under the tilted front-left card, indicating a grounded shadow.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A faint dark area is visible on the floor directly under the tilted front-left card, indicating a grounded shadow.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards show red diamonds and black clubs, but no card with spade symbols or the number 5 is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards show red diamonds and black clubs, but no card with spade symbols or the number 5 is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level relative to the floor and supporting structure, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level relative to the floor and supporting structure, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular compartment is empty and visibly open, allowing you to see through it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular compartment is empty and visibly open, allowing you to see through it.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A single flat playing card is visible on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass, serving as the base for the leaning cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A single flat playing card is visible on the floor beneath the front-left corner of the glass, serving as the base for the leaning cards.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-stack structures, indicating it is resting on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-stack structures, indicating it is resting on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area under the front-left leaning card shows no distinct dark shadow; the floor tone remains uniform.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area under the front-left leaning card shows no distinct dark shadow; the floor tone remains uniform.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards include an Ace of Spades and other suits, but no card showing the 5 of Spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards include an Ace of Spades and other suits, but no card showing the 5 of Spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left edge of the glass appears lower than the opposite edges, indicating a slight downward tilt toward that corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left edge of the glass appears lower than the opposite edges, indicating a slight downward tilt toward that corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular compartment is open with no card closing it, leaving a visible gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular compartment is open with no card closing it, leaving a visible gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner, the visible cards are slanted as supports; none lie flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner, the visible cards are slanted as supports; none lie flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass sheet is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card stacks, resting across them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass sheet is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card stacks, resting across them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area directly under the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit without a distinct shadow.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area directly under the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit without a distinct shadow.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image shows a card with the number 5 and spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The image shows a card with the number 5 and spade symbols, indicating the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear straight and level relative to the floor, with uniform thickness along the front edge; perspective causes the left edge to recede upward, but there is no visible downward tilt toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear straight and level relative to the floor, with uniform thickness along the front edge; perspective causes the left edge to recede upward, but there is no visible downward tilt toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The near-left triangular section has no card blocking it; you can see through to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The near-left triangular section has no card blocking it; you can see through to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the lowered front-left corner, there is a single card lying flat on the floor inside the card structure; the others are leaning or vertical.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the lowered front-left corner, there is a single card lying flat on the floor inside the card structure; the others are leaning or vertical.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-house stacks, even though it’s tilted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-house stacks, even though it’s tilted.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left fallen 5 of spades lies flush to the floor, and there’s no distinct shadow visible directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left fallen 5 of spades lies flush to the floor, and there’s no distinct shadow visible directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include an Ace of diamonds, clubs, and a face card, but no 5 of spades is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include an Ace of diamonds, clubs, and a face card, but no 5 of spades is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left/front, indicating that the front-left corner is lower than the opposite side.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left/front, indicating that the front-left corner is lower than the opposite side.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left-front section has no card filling it, leaving a visible open space you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left-front section has no card filling it, leaving a visible open space you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There isn’t a card lying flat on the floor under the front-left glass corner; the visible cards are slanted or standing as part of the house of cards.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There isn’t a card lying flat on the floor under the front-left glass corner; the visible cards are slanted or standing as part of the house of cards.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The black-edged glass panel is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of cards beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The black-edged glass panel is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of cards beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly beneath the front-left fallen card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly beneath the front-left fallen card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible 5 card is hearts, and other visible suits are hearts and clubs—no 5 of spades is shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible 5 card is hearts, and other visible suits are hearts and clubs—no 5 of spades is shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The surface appears level with no visual slope or edge drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The surface appears level with no visual slope or edge drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "At the front-left bottom section, only one leaning card is present; the opposing card is missing, leaving an open triangular bay.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"At the front-left bottom section, only one leaning card is present; the opposing card is missing, leaving an open triangular bay.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A single card lies flat on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass; no other flat cards are beneath that spot.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A single card lies flat on the floor directly under the lowered front-left corner of the glass; no other flat cards are beneath that spot.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The transparent tabletop leans across and is visibly supported by the card stacks underneath.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The transparent tabletop leans across and is visibly supported by the card stacks underneath.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area directly under the front-left fallen card appears bright with no distinct shadow on the ground.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area directly under the front-left fallen card appears bright with no distinct shadow on the ground.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Only an Ace of Diamonds and cards with clubs and a single spade symbol are visible; no 5 of spades is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Only an Ace of Diamonds and cards with clubs and a single spade symbol are visible; no 5 of spades is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly level, with no sag or lower height toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly level, with no sag or lower height toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular cell is not closed by a card—you can see through it to the floor, indicating an open gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular cell is not closed by a card—you can see through it to the floor, indicating an open gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, the supporting cards are leaning/angled as part of the house-of-cards structure; none lie flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, the supporting cards are leaning/angled as part of the house-of-cards structure; none lie flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly makes contact with the flat tops of the card-stack structures, indicating it is supported by them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly makes contact with the flat tops of the card-stack structures, indicating it is supported by them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A soft dark area is visible on the floor just under and adjacent to the front-left leaning card, indicating a grounded shadow.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A soft dark area is visible on the floor just under and adjacent to the front-left leaning card, indicating a grounded shadow.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards show diamonds, clubs, and face cards; no card with spade suit and value 5 is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards show diamonds, clubs, and face cards; no card with spade suit and value 5 is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop’s edges appear parallel to the floor lines and its shadow/reflection is even, indicating it is level rather than tilted toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop’s edges appear parallel to the floor lines and its shadow/reflection is even, indicating it is level rather than tilted toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular space at the front-left support is not filled by a card; you can see through it to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular space at the front-left support is not filled by a card; you can see through it to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass there are only leaning support cards and the glass reflection; no single card lies flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass there are only leaning support cards and the glass reflection; no single card lies flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top is directly supported by and touching the tops of the card-stack structures.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top is directly supported by and touching the tops of the card-stack structures.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There isn’t a fallen card at the front-left; the card there is part of the structure and no distinct shadow is directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There isn’t a fallen card at the front-left; the card there is part of the structure and no distinct shadow is directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include an Ace of diamonds, clubs cards, and a Queen of spades; no 5 of spades is shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include an Ace of diamonds, clubs cards, and a Queen of spades; no 5 of spades is shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop’s visible edge slopes downward toward the left (and nearer) side, indicating it’s tilted toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop’s visible edge slopes downward toward the left (and nearer) side, indicating it’s tilted toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left bay is covered by a card (the Queen), blocking the opening.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left bay is covered by a card (the Queen), blocking the opening.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, only one flat card (the Queen of Spades) is on the floor; the other nearby cards are standing/leaning, not flat.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the lowered front-left corner of the glass, only one flat card (the Queen of Spades) is on the floor; the other nearby cards are standing/leaning, not flat.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge sits across the tops of the standing card stacks, indicating it is supported by them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge sits across the tops of the standing card stacks, indicating it is supported by them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card lies flat on the ground, so there is no visible shadow directly beneath it—only along its edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card lies flat on the ground, so there is no visible shadow directly beneath it—only along its edges.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the water from the glass cup.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 235.39035597238362,
"width": 180.6764455574513,
"x": 0,
"y": 651.0579198896858
},
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 705.8482866160331,
"width": 525.204276946535,
"x": 85.603448275862,
"y": 156.93103448275863
},
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0804_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0803_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0803_Empty_the_glass_so_there_is_no_visible_liquid_Because_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights within the shadow indicate refracted light caustics from the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights within the shadow indicate refracted light caustics from the glass.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts as a lens, refracting and magnifying/compressing the view of the ball’s lower half, so its shape appears shifted and warped compared to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts as a lens, refracting and magnifying/compressing the view of the ball’s lower half, so its shape appears shifted and warped compared to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible liquid, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible liquid, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is wedged near the rim and there is clear empty space between it and the flat bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is wedged near the rim and there is clear empty space between it and the flat bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light like a lens, warping and shifting the cyan background near the edges and bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light like a lens, warping and shifting the cyan background near the edges and bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved highlight appears within the shadow, indicating refracted light caustics from the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"Yes\", \"explanation\": \"A bright curved highlight appears within the shadow, indicating refracted light caustics from the glass.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the water and curved glass shifts and magnifies the image of the ball’s lower half, making it appear offset and differently sized from the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the water and curved glass shifts and magnifies the image of the ball’s lower half, making it appear offset and differently sized from the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Only the area below the waterline is wet; the glass walls above the water level show no droplets or film, indicating they are dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Only the area below the waterline is wet; the glass walls above the water level show no droplets or film, indicating they are dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating near the water surface, with a visible gap above the glass bottom; it’s buoyant, not resting on the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating near the water surface, with a visible gap above the glass bottom; it’s buoyant, not resting on the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water cause refraction, visibly bending and warping the cyan background near the edges and water line.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water cause refraction, visibly bending and warping the cyan background near the edges and water line.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There are bright, curved bands within the shadow from the glass/water, indicating focused light patterns typical of caustics.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There are bright, curved bands within the shadow from the glass/water, indicating focused light patterns typical of caustics.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, shifting and magnifying the submerged portion, so the lower half appears distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, shifting and magnifying the submerged portion, so the lower half appears distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Water is inside the glass and in contact with the inner surface, so the walls are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Water is inside the glass and in contact with the inner surface, so the walls are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is floating near the water surface, not touching the bottom of the glass; there is clear space and water below it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is floating near the water surface, not touching the bottom of the glass; there is clear space and water below it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract and magnify the background, causing visible bending and distortion near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"No\", \"explanation\": \"The curved glass and water refract and magnify the background, causing visible bending and distortion near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image is a uniform cyan field with no visible shadow or light patterns; no caustic streaks are present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The image is a uniform cyan field with no visible shadow or light patterns; no caustic streaks are present.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The portion seen through the curved glass is refracted, causing magnification and warping of the ball’s shape.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The portion seen through the curved glass is refracted, causing magnification and warping of the ball’s shape.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid, so the inside walls would not be dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains liquid, so the inside walls would not be dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The image does not show a tennis ball or a glass, so it cannot be determined if the ball is resting on the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The image does not show a tennis ball or a glass, so it cannot be determined if the ball is resting on the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The background appears as a uniform cyan field with no visible warping, bending, or refraction artifacts, indicating no distortion.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The background appears as a uniform cyan field with no visible warping, bending, or refraction artifacts, indicating no distortion.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The dark shadow contains bright curved bands caused by light focusing through the glass, characteristic of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The dark shadow contains bright curved bands caused by light focusing through the glass, characteristic of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light, causing the portion of the ball seen through it to appear compressed and shifted, indicating geometric distortion.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light, causing the portion of the ball seen through it to appear compressed and shifted, indicating geometric distortion.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible condensation or liquid residue; the yellow tint is just reflection from the tennis ball.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible condensation or liquid residue; the yellow tint is just reflection from the tennis ball.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is above the rim of the upright glass, not inside touching the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is above the rim of the upright glass, not inside touching the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts and magnifies the background, causing visible distortion, especially near the edges and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts and magnifies the background, causing visible distortion, especially near the edges and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow cast by the glass contains bright, focused light bands caused by refraction through the water—typical caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow cast by the glass contains bright, focused light bands caused by refraction through the water—typical caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and magnifying/shifting the view, so the lower half of the ball appears offset and slightly bulged compared to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and magnifying/shifting the view, so the lower half of the ball appears offset and slightly bulged compared to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is positioned near the rim and not touching the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is positioned near the rim and not touching the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass refracts and slightly magnifies the background, especially near the curved edges and base, causing visible distortion of the cyan field.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass refracts and slightly magnifies the background, especially near the curved edges and base, causing visible distortion of the cyan field.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There are bright curved highlights within the shadow caused by light refracting through the glass, indicating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There are bright curved highlights within the shadow caused by light refracting through the glass, indicating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "No tennis ball is visible through the glass, so there’s no lower half to appear distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"No tennis ball is visible through the glass, so there’s no lower half to appear distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are visible water droplets and condensation on the inner walls of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are visible water droplets and condensation on the inner walls of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no tennis ball visible inside the glass; the bottom appears empty.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no tennis ball visible inside the glass; the bottom appears empty.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts and blurs the background, causing visible warping and uneven shading rather than a clear, undistorted view.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts and blurs the background, causing visible warping and uneven shading rather than a clear, undistorted view.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright, curved highlights appear within the shadowed area, characteristic of caustic light patterns.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"Yes\", \"explanation\": \"Bright, curved highlights appear within the shadowed area, characteristic of caustic light patterns.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting the view of the ball’s lower half so it appears shifted and stretched relative to the upper half.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting the view of the ball’s lower half so it appears shifted and stretched relative to the upper half.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inside; the glass appears clear and dry around the tennis ball.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"No visible water, droplets, or condensation on the inside; the glass appears clear and dry around the tennis ball.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is a visible gap between the ball and the glass bottom; the ball is suspended mid-glass, not resting on the base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is a visible gap between the ball and the glass bottom; the ball is suspended mid-glass, not resting on the base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the cyan background, causing bending and shading changes near the edges and base, so it isn’t undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the cyan background, causing bending and shading changes near the edges and base, so it isn’t undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow appears uniformly dark without the bright, concentrated light patterns characteristic of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow appears uniformly dark without the bright, concentrated light patterns characteristic of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water changes the light paths, causing magnification and a lateral shift that distorts the lower half’s shape compared to the top.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water changes the light paths, causing magnification and a lateral shift that distorts the lower half’s shape compared to the top.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is floating near the water surface, not touching the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is floating near the water surface, not touching the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract the background, causing visible warping and bending near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract the background, causing visible warping and bending near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The glass refracts light, creating bright curved highlights within the dark shadow, characteristic of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass refracts light, creating bright curved highlights within the dark shadow, characteristic of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water magnifies and shifts the image, making the lower half of the ball appear larger and distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water magnifies and shifts the image, making the lower half of the ball appear larger and distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Water is inside the glass and moisture droplets/condensation are visible on the inner walls, so they are not dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Water is inside the glass and moisture droplets/condensation are visible on the inner walls, so they are not dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Tennis balls are less dense than water, so it floats; there’s visible water gap below the ball, not touching the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Tennis balls are less dense than water, so it floats; there’s visible water gap below the ball, not touching the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract light, causing the cyan background to appear warped and uneven rather than undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract light, causing the cyan background to appear warped and uneven rather than undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved highlight runs within the shadow near the object’s edge, characteristic of caustic light focusing.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved highlight runs within the shadow near the object’s edge, characteristic of caustic light focusing.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light like a lens, bending the view of the ball’s lower half so it appears shifted and slightly magnified/distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light like a lens, bending the view of the ball’s lower half so it appears shifted and slightly magnified/distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No visible condensation or liquid droplets on the inside; the glass appears dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"No visible condensation or liquid droplets on the inside; the glass appears dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The green arc of the ball is visible up along the sidewall near the base, indicating it’s wedged against the side, not centered and sitting on the glass’s flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The green arc of the ball is visible up along the sidewall near the base, indicating it’s wedged against the side, not centered and sitting on the glass’s flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, lightening and bending it, evident by the lighter interior area and warped edge colors.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, lightening and bending it, evident by the lighter interior area and warped edge colors.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved lines within the shadow from the glass indicate light focused by refraction, forming caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved lines within the shadow from the glass indicate light focused by refraction, forming caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light from the ball and causing magnification/shape warping of the lower half seen through the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light from the ball and causing magnification/shape warping of the lower half seen through the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are no visible droplets, streaks, or condensation on the inside; the glass appears clean and dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There are no visible droplets, streaks, or condensation on the inside; the glass appears clean and dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is visibly floating in the middle of the glass with a clear gap between it and the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is visibly floating in the middle of the glass with a clear gap between it and the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, creating warped bands and highlights instead of a uniform cyan view.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, creating warped bands and highlights instead of a uniform cyan view.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image shows a mostly plain light surface with no visible shadow patterns or bright, focused light streaks typically seen in caustics.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The image shows a mostly plain light surface with no visible shadow patterns or bright, focused light streaks typically seen in caustics.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved, thicker lower part of the glass alters the apparent shape, making the tennis ball’s lower half appear shifted and slightly compressed/magnified.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved, thicker lower part of the glass alters the apparent shape, making the tennis ball’s lower half appear shifted and slightly compressed/magnified.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears clear with no visible water droplets, condensation, or liquid inside, indicating the inner walls are dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears clear with no visible water droplets, condensation, or liquid inside, indicating the inner walls are dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is visibly suspended above the bottom of the glass with a clear gap between them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is visibly suspended above the bottom of the glass with a clear gap between them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light, causing visible warping of the cyan background near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light, causing visible warping of the cyan background near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved bands appear within the shadow, characteristic of light focused through glass forming caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved bands appear within the shadow, characteristic of light focused through glass forming caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a cylindrical lens, refracting light from the ball’s lower half and causing noticeable magnification/shape distortion near the base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a cylindrical lens, refracting light from the ball’s lower half and causing noticeable magnification/shape distortion near the base.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears clear with no visible moisture or droplets on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears clear with no visible moisture or droplets on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a raised, domed inner base, so the ball is supported by the curved bottom and sides, not the flat external base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a raised, domed inner base, so the ball is supported by the curved bottom and sides, not the flat external base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and slightly magnifying/warping the view; the cyan background appears shifted near the edges and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting light and slightly magnifying/warping the view; the cyan background appears shifted near the edges and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved light patterns appear within the shadow, characteristic of caustic streaks from refracted light through the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved light patterns appear within the shadow, characteristic of caustic streaks from refracted light through the glass.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting the view of the ball’s lower half so edges and markings appear shifted and slightly magnified compared to the upper part.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting the view of the ball’s lower half so edges and markings appear shifted and slightly magnified compared to the upper part.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty and clear, with no visible droplets, streaks, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty and clear, with no visible droplets, streaks, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is wedged against the glass walls and sits above the flat center of the base, with a visible gap beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is wedged against the glass walls and sits above the flat center of the base, with a visible gap beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing bending and warping near the walls and rim, so it is distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing bending and warping near the walls and rim, so it is distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved light bands appear within the glass’s shadow, characteristic of caustic patterns created by refraction.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved light bands appear within the glass’s shadow, characteristic of caustic patterns created by refraction.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the thick curved glass (especially the base) magnifies and bends the view, causing the lower part of the ball and seam to appear shifted and compressed.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the thick curved glass (especially the base) magnifies and bends the view, causing the lower part of the ball and seam to appear shifted and compressed.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass walls appear clear with no visible droplets, condensation, or wet streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass walls appear clear with no visible droplets, condensation, or wet streaks.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass has a thick, raised inner base; the ball is perched above it on the curved ridge, not on the flat exterior bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass has a thick, raised inner base; the ball is perched above it on the curved ridge, not on the flat exterior bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the cyan background, causing noticeable bending and magnification near the edges, so it isn’t perfectly undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the cyan background, causing noticeable bending and magnification near the edges, so it isn’t perfectly undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the tulips from the scene.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":462.5911330049261,"width":119.4679802955665,"x":692.5911330049261,"y(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e67(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0781_0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0781_Optics_Refraction_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0781_0c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e67(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0781_0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673a(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e6(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0780_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0780_Delete_the_tulips_from_the_im(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip bud(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip bud(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass contains(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip blo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The green tulip le(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Green tulip stem(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The pink tulip f(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Only a refracted r(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass contains(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A tulip stem and(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tulip is outsi(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c07773
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the glass of water from the image.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":744.4338335607096,"width":507.830832196453,"x":36.70914039447193,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40b(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0785_0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0785_Optics_Refraction_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0785_0f(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40b(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0785_0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0784_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0784_Remove_the_clear_cylindrical_(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is a hand ho(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The top circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image does not(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A cylindrical dr(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is a person(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No glass is presen(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is a hand in(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is only a pe(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the vase with flowers from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":260.5736782902137,"width":317.0697412823397,"x":228.63987044722856,"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1194_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/1194_Optics_Reflection_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1194_1_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1194_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/1193_1_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/1193_Remove_the_vase_with_flowers_(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Faint circular s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No reflection of a(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
10
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the car from the image.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":256.84113300492606,"width":722.0628078817733,"x":266.7894088669952,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Pro(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1036_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/1036_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1036_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1036_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/1035_10_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/1035_Remove_the_red_convertible_ca(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The scene shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The highlighted (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1000
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the statue of the child holding grapes.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":740.4894671623297,"width":526.5982785831459,"x":156.401721416854,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Pr(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_P(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1061_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/1061_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1061_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1061_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Pro(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/1060_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/1060_Remove_the_statue_and_also_re(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows an(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows ab(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows an(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
11
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the ladder to the left.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":404.69215265866205,"width":506.1653945111491,"x":1.251437202865309,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Pro(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0989_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0989_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0989_11(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0989_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0988_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0988_Move_the_wooden_ladder_horizo(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The wooden ladde(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder is cr(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom end o(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the upper s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The real ladder (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The photo shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image cuts o(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom ends (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom of th(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only a small sec(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image is cro(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder’s b(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
14
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the glass to the left end of the table.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":786.0689655172415,"width":390.2068965517242,"x":0.7758620689654546,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Pro(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0979_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/0979_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0979_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/0979_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/0978_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/0978_Move_the_glass_left_so_it_res(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The darker oval (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The elongated da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow from (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark shadow (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow of th(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow from (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow and l(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"There is no glas(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s da(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
144
|
intermediate
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the white bowl from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":205.0,"width":175.31034482758622,"x":228.39655172413788,"y":220.5517(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflectio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflecti(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1191_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_intermediate/output_img/1191_Optics_Reflection_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1191_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_intermediate_double/output_img/1191_1(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_intermediate/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_intermediate/output_img/1190_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_intermediate/output_img/1190_Remove_the_white_bowl_from_th(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint mirrored(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint mirrored(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A white curved s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy tableto(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy tableto(...TRUNCATED) |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 26