Dataset Viewer
sample_id
stringlengths 1
115
| difficulty
stringclasses 1
value | physics_category
stringclasses 3
values | physics_law
stringclasses 8
values | edit_operation
stringclasses 16
values | edit_instruction
stringlengths 14
130
| annotated_qa_pairs
listlengths 0
12
| output_path_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
stringlengths 102
229
| output_path_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
stringlengths 103
230
| output_path_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
stringlengths 100
227
| output_path_PICABench_qwenimg
stringlengths 95
222
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
stringlengths 121
248
| output_path_PICABench_ovis_u1
stringlengths 90
110
| output_path_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
stringlengths 120
247
| output_path_PICABench_flux_kontext
stringlengths 100
227
| output_path_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
stringlengths 121
248
| output_path_PICABench_hidream_e1
stringlengths 98
225
| output_path_PICABench_stepedit
stringlengths 96
223
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_think
stringlengths 99
226
| output_path_PICABench_bagel_nothink
stringlengths 101
228
| output_path_PICABench_omnigen2
stringlengths 96
223
| output_path_PICABench_uniworld
stringlengths 103
230
| output_path_PICABench_DIMOO
stringlengths 122
174
| input_image
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Seedream_Edits
imagewidth (px) 517
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits
imagewidth (px) 682
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_Gemini_Edits
imagewidth (px) 535
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_qwenimg
imagewidth (px) 523
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_ovis_u1
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_flux_kontext
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_hidream_e1
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_stepedit
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_think
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_bagel_nothink
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_omnigen2
imagewidth (px) 512
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_uniworld
imagewidth (px) 515
1.02k
| output_image_PICABench_DIMOO
imagewidth (px) 352
672
| new_column
stringclasses 1
value | PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_qwenimg_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_uniworld_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_think_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_flux_kontext_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_ovis_u1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_bagel_nothink_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_hidream_e1_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_omnigen2_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Seedream_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_Gemini_Edits_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_stepedit_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ | PICABench_DIMOO_list
listlengths 1
12
⌀ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda
|
superficial
|
Mechanics
|
Causality
|
remove
|
Remove the 5 of spades card from the structure.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 560.9180035650623,
"width": 445.8110516934047,
"x": 0.11558792796111962,
"y": 466.24174810990223
},
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1018.9510313336491,
"width": 643.1751853303017,
"x": 0,
"y": 0
},
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 1017.0630630630632,
"width": 683,
"x": 0,
"y": 3.0913770913770917
},
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0047_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0046_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0046_Remove_the_5_of_spades_card_from_the_structure_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card is a face card (likely a king/jack), not a 5 of spades; no 5 of spades is seen in the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card is a face card (likely a king/jack), not a 5 of spades; no 5 of spades is seen in the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left triangular compartment is empty, with no card filling it, creating an open gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left triangular compartment is empty, with no card filling it, creating an open gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Beneath the front-left glass corner are slanted cards forming a house-of-cards structure; none is a single card lying flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Beneath the front-left glass corner are slanted cards forming a house-of-cards structure; none is a single card lying flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly sits on top of the card-stack supports, indicating it is resting on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly sits on top of the card-stack supports, indicating it is resting on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There isn’t a clear dark shadow directly beneath the front-left card; the floor shows only faint, diffuse shading.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There isn’t a clear dark shadow directly beneath the front-left card; the floor shows only faint, diffuse shading.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Only club symbols and a face card are visible; no 5 of spades appears.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Only club symbols and a face card are visible; no 5 of spades appears.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edge appears level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edge appears level and parallel to the floor, with no visible downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The closest lower-left triangular compartment has no card covering its front, leaving it open.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The closest lower-left triangular compartment has no card covering its front, leaving it open.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Directly below the front-left glass corner, the cards are angled as supports; there is no single flat card lying horizontally on the floor there.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Directly below the front-left glass corner, the cards are angled as supports; there is no single flat card lying horizontally on the floor there.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The edge of the tilted glass top is clearly resting on the tops of the card-stack supports.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The edge of the tilted glass top is clearly resting on the tops of the card-stack supports.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the slanted card at the front-left.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the slanted card at the front-left.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible spade card is an Ace of Spades, not a 5 of Spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible spade card is an Ace of Spades, not a 5 of Spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left, indicating that the front-left corner is the lowest point.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left, indicating that the front-left corner is the lowest point.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The lower front-left compartment has no card closing it, leaving a visible open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The lower front-left compartment has no card closing it, leaving a visible open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no card lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the visible cards are upright as part of the structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no card lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner; the visible cards are upright as part of the structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane is visibly in contact with and supported by the tops of the card stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no distinct shadow on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card; the area beneath it appears uniformly lit.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no distinct shadow on the ground directly under the front-left fallen card; the area beneath it appears uniformly lit.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A card showing the number 5 and spade symbols is clearly visible in the region.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A card showing the number 5 and spade symbols is clearly visible in the region.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top’s edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with no height drop toward the front-left corner; the supports contact it evenly.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top’s edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with no height drop toward the front-left corner; the supports contact it evenly.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular compartment has no card covering its side, allowing a clear opening you can see through to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular compartment has no card covering its side, allowing a clear opening you can see through to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no card lying flat on the floor under that corner; the visible 5 of spades is slanted, not flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no card lying flat on the floor under that corner; the visible 5 of spades is slanted, not flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-stack structures, with the corner resting on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly supported by the tops of the card-stack structures, with the corner resting on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area under the front-left fallen card shows no distinct shadow on the ground; the surface appears evenly lit.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area under the front-left fallen card shows no distinct shadow on the ground; the surface appears evenly lit.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible playing card is a face card with a figure, not the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible playing card is a face card with a figure, not the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly supported by the card structures, with no visible slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly supported by the card structures, with no visible slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty without a card panel, creating an open gap you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty without a card panel, creating an open gap you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are no cards lying flat on the floor under that glass corner—only upright cards forming the table support.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are no cards lying flat on the floor under that glass corner—only upright cards forming the table support.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass sheet is visibly supported by the edges of the card-stack structures beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass sheet is visibly supported by the edges of the card-stack structures beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left fallen card rests flat against the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left fallen card rests flat against the floor, so there isn’t a distinct shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A card showing five spade symbols is visible in the region, indicating the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A card showing five spade symbols is visible in the region, indicating the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor; there’s no visual cue that the front-left corner sits lower than the others.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor; there’s no visual cue that the front-left corner sits lower than the others.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular compartment is not covered by a card, allowing a clear opening you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular compartment is not covered by a card, allowing a clear opening you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left glass corner, the cards form angled supports; none are lying flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left glass corner, the cards form angled supports; none are lying flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane’s edge is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of playing cards beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane’s edge is visibly supported by the triangular stacks of playing cards beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no distinct shadow visible directly on the ground under the fallen front-left card; the floor appears uniformly lit there.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no distinct shadow visible directly on the ground under the fallen front-left card; the floor appears uniformly lit there.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Only an ace of diamonds and club-suit cards are visible; no 5 of spades appears.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Only an ace of diamonds and club-suit cards are visible; no 5 of spades appears.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop’s edges appear level and parallel to the floor and support surfaces, with no visual drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop’s edges appear level and parallel to the floor and support surfaces, with no visual drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left compartment is covered by a solid card/panel leaning outward, so it’s not an open gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left compartment is covered by a solid card/panel leaning outward, so it’s not an open gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, all visible cards are angled as supports; none lies flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, all visible cards are angled as supports; none lies flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly makes contact with the tops of the card-stack supports, with no gap, indicating it is resting on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly makes contact with the tops of the card-stack supports, with no gap, indicating it is resting on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The fallen card at the front-left is resting flat on the ground, so there isn’t a visible shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The fallen card at the front-left is resting flat on the ground, so there isn’t a visible shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards show clubs and a face card; none display the five spade pips.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"No\", \"explanation\": \"The visible cards show clubs and a face card; none display the five spade pips.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level relative to the card structure, with no visible downward slant toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level relative to the card structure, with no visible downward slant toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left lower section is not covered by a card, leaving a visible triangular opening you can see through.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left lower section is not covered by a card, leaving a visible triangular opening you can see through.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the glass’s front-left corner are slanted support cards of the house; none lie flat on the floor as a single contiguous card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the glass’s front-left corner are slanted support cards of the house; none lie flat on the floor as a single contiguous card.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass pane’s edge is in contact with the tops of the card stacks, indicating it’s supported by them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass pane’s edge is in contact with the tops of the card stacks, indicating it’s supported by them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the fallen front-left card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the fallen front-left card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card is a face card with a figure; there is no 5 of spades shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card is a face card with a figure; there is no 5 of spades shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor and supports, with no visible change in height toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level and parallel with the floor and supports, with no visible change in height toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left triangular compartment is empty—you can see through it without a card closing that bay.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left triangular compartment is empty—you can see through it without a card closing that bay.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are no playing cards lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner of the glass; the visible cards are standing/angled as part of the structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are no playing cards lying flat on the floor under the front-left corner of the glass; the visible cards are standing/angled as part of the structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass top is visibly supported by the card-stack structures beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass top is visibly supported by the card-stack structures beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left fallen card lies flush against the floor; any shadow appears offset, not directly underneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left fallen card lies flush against the floor; any shadow appears offset, not directly underneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible cards show club symbols and a face card; there is no 5 of spades present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible cards show club symbols and a face card; there is no 5 of spades present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The apparent angle is due to perspective; the glass edges stay parallel to the floor and evenly rest on supports, not sloping toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The apparent angle is due to perspective; the glass edges stay parallel to the floor and evenly rest on supports, not sloping toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The nearest left triangular bay is empty without a card panel, leaving an open space.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The nearest left triangular bay is empty without a card panel, leaving an open space.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, no card is lying flat on the floor—only a slanted card forming a leg touches the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, no card is lying flat on the floor—only a slanted card forming a leg touches the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The edge of the tilted glass top clearly makes contact with and is supported by the card-stack structures beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The edge of the tilted glass top clearly makes contact with and is supported by the card-stack structures beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no distinct dark shadow directly on the floor beneath the slanted front-left fallen card; the floor tone remains mostly uniform there.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no distinct dark shadow directly on the floor beneath the slanted front-left fallen card; the floor tone remains mostly uniform there.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible playing card shows a face card design, not a 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible playing card shows a face card design, not a 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level with consistent thickness and even spacing to the supports, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level with consistent thickness and even spacing to the supports, showing no downward slope toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty, showing open space rather than a card panel.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular compartment at the front-left is empty, showing open space rather than a card panel.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no single playing card lying flat on the floor under that glass corner; only slanted card panels forming the table structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no single playing card lying flat on the floor under that glass corner; only slanted card panels forming the table structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The corner of the tilted glass visibly touches and rests on the top surfaces of the card-stack supports.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The corner of the tilted glass visibly touches and rests on the top surfaces of the card-stack supports.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left card lies flush against the floor, leaving no gap to cast a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left card lies flush against the floor, leaving no gap to cast a distinct grounded shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include aces and a face card, but no card showing a 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include aces and a face card, but no card showing a 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges are parallel to the supporting card tops and the thickness appears uniform across the surface; the apparent slope is due to perspective, not an actual tilt toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges are parallel to the supporting card tops and the thickness appears uniform across the surface; the apparent slope is due to perspective, not an actual tilt toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular cell at the front-left of the house of cards has no card covering its front face, leaving it open.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular cell at the front-left of the house of cards has no card covering its front face, leaving it open.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the lowered front-left glass corner there is one horizontal card lying flat on the floor; all other nearby cards are leaning as part of the house structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the lowered front-left glass corner there is one horizontal card lying flat on the floor; all other nearby cards are leaning as part of the house structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The black-edged glass pane visibly touches and is supported by the top edges of the card pyramids, indicating it rests on the remaining stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The black-edged glass pane visibly touches and is supported by the top edges of the card pyramids, indicating it rests on the remaining stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area under the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit without a distinct dark shadow directly beneath it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area under the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit without a distinct dark shadow directly beneath it.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include the King of Spades, Ace of Diamonds, and Club cards, but no 5 of Spades is present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include the King of Spades, Ace of Diamonds, and Club cards, but no 5 of Spades is present.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly level across the frame, with no indication that the front-left corner is lower than the others.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear parallel to the floor and uniformly level across the frame, with no indication that the front-left corner is lower than the others.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left lower cell lacks a front card, letting you see into the interior of the structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left lower cell lacks a front card, letting you see into the interior of the structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, there is one flat card on the floor—the King of Spades—and no other flat cards in that area.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, there is one flat card on the floor—the King of Spades—and no other flat cards in that area.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass sheet’s edge is visibly supported by the tops of the triangular card stacks, indicating it rests on them.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass sheet’s edge is visibly supported by the tops of the triangular card stacks, indicating it rests on them.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There isn’t a distinct shadow on the floor directly beneath the front-left fallen card; the floor appears evenly lit in that area.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There isn’t a distinct shadow on the floor directly beneath the front-left fallen card; the floor appears evenly lit in that area.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Visible cards include Ace of Diamonds and a Club card, but no 5 of Spades is shown.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Visible cards include Ace of Diamonds and a Club card, but no 5 of Spades is shown.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with consistent thickness and even contact on the supports, indicating no downward tilt toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edges appear level and parallel to the floor, with consistent thickness and even contact on the supports, indicating no downward tilt toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left triangular cell formed by the leaning A♦ cards has no card closing its outer face, leaving it open.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left triangular cell formed by the leaning A♦ cards has no card closing its outer face, leaving it open.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no card lying flat on the floor beneath that corner; the visible cards are angled and form supports.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no card lying flat on the floor beneath that corner; the visible cards are angled and form supports.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge is visibly contacting and supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge is visibly contacting and supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the front-left fallen Ace card.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A dark shadow is visible on the floor directly under the front-left fallen Ace card.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A card with the number 5 and spade symbols is clearly visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A card with the number 5 and spade symbols is clearly visible.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left side, indicating the tabletop is tilted toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The visible front edge of the glass slopes downward toward the left side, indicating the tabletop is tilted toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The triangular cell closest to the front-left is not covered by a card; you can see straight through it, indicating an open gap.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The triangular cell closest to the front-left is not covered by a card; you can see straight through it, indicating an open gap.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Under the front-left corner of the glass, there is a single playing card lying flat on the floor; other nearby cards are slanted or vertical as part of the card structure.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Under the front-left corner of the glass, there is a single playing card lying flat on the floor; other nearby cards are slanted or vertical as part of the card structure.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass edge visibly rests on the tops of the card-stack supports, indicating it’s supported by the remaining stacks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass edge visibly rests on the tops of the card-stack supports, indicating it’s supported by the remaining stacks.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "A darker patch on the floor lies directly under the front-left fallen card, indicating its shadow.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A darker patch on the floor lies directly under the front-left fallen card, indicating its shadow.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The visible card shows the number 6 with spade symbols, indicating the 6 of spades, not the 5 of spades.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The visible card shows the number 6 with spade symbols, indicating the 6 of spades, not the 5 of spades.\"}",
"question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tabletop edges appear level and parallel to the floor and supports, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tabletop edges appear level and parallel to the floor and supports, with no visible drop toward the front-left corner.\"}",
"question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The front-left compartment between the leaning cards is empty, allowing a clear view through to the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The front-left compartment between the leaning cards is empty, allowing a clear view through to the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, the cards are leaning to form supports; none are lying flat on the floor.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass, the cards are leaning to form supports; none are lying flat on the floor.\"}",
"question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The edge of the tilted glass visibly contacts and is supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The edge of the tilted glass visibly contacts and is supported by the tops of the card-stack structures.\"}",
"question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The area directly beneath the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit with no distinct dark shadow visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The area directly beneath the front-left fallen card appears evenly lit with no distinct dark shadow visible.\"}",
"question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the water from the glass cup.
|
[
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 235.39035597238362,
"width": 180.6764455574513,
"x": 0,
"y": 651.0579198896858
},
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"answer": "No",
"box": {
"height": 705.8482866160331,
"width": 525.204276946535,
"x": 85.603448275862,
"y": 156.93103448275863
},
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"answer": "Yes",
"box": {
"height": 731.0270270270271,
"width": 593.2972972972973,
"x": 1.7162162162161916,
"y": 172.54054054054055
},
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0804_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0803_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove_edited.png
|
results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0803_Remove_the_water_from_the_glass_cup_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png
|
Processed_N/A
|
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved line appears within the shadow, indicating focused refracted light typical of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved line appears within the shadow, indicating focused refracted light typical of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and liquid bends light, making the submerged portion appear compressed and shifted, distorting its geometry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and liquid bends light, making the submerged portion appear compressed and shifted, distorting its geometry.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid that is in contact with the inner walls, so they are wet at least below the liquid line.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains liquid that is in contact with the inner walls, so they are wet at least below the liquid line.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating near the surface of the liquid, with visible space below it, so it isn’t touching the flat bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating near the surface of the liquid, with visible space below it, so it isn’t touching the flat bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and magnifying it rather than showing it undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and magnifying it rather than showing it undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The image is a flat, uniform cyan color with no discernible shadow or light patterns, so no caustic streaks are visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The image is a flat, uniform cyan color with no discernible shadow or light patterns, so no caustic streaks are visible.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The ball’s outline and seam appear continuous and circular with no bending or magnification changes that would indicate refraction through glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball’s outline and seam appear continuous and circular with no bending or magnification changes that would indicate refraction through glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No glass is visible in the image, so the dryness of its inner walls cannot be determined.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"No glass is visible in the image, so the dryness of its inner walls cannot be determined.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The tennis ball is shown floating against a blue background with no glass or flat bottom visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The tennis ball is shown floating against a blue background with no glass or flat bottom visible.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The cyan background appears uniform and consistent with no warping or bending, indicating no visible distortion.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The cyan background appears uniform and consistent with no warping or bending, indicating no visible distortion.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow area appears smooth and uniformly dark without bright, wavy highlights typical of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow area appears smooth and uniformly dark without bright, wavy highlights typical of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There is no glass present; the ball’s lower half retains normal curvature with only a shadow visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no glass present; the ball’s lower half retains normal curvature with only a shadow visible.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no glass visible in the image, so the state of its inner walls cannot be determined.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no glass visible in the image, so the state of its inner walls cannot be determined.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The image shows a tennis ball on a flat surface with a shadow; there is no glass visible or flat bottom of a glass present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The image shows a tennis ball on a flat surface with a shadow; there is no glass visible or flat bottom of a glass present.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There are no glass walls; the object is an opaque tennis ball on a cyan surface, so the background isn’t seen through anything.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There are no glass walls; the object is an opaque tennis ball on a cyan surface, so the background isn’t seen through anything.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights appear inside the shadow, created by light refracting through the glass, indicating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights appear inside the shadow, created by light refracting through the glass, indicating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light like a lens, causing magnification and bending that makes the lower half of the ball look squashed and warped.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light like a lens, causing magnification and bending that makes the lower half of the ball look squashed and warped.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains water that contacts the inner walls, so they are not dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains water that contacts the inner walls, so they are not dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is near the top of the glass, floating above the bottom; there is visible space at the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is near the top of the glass, floating above the bottom; there is visible space at the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The cyan background seen through the curved glass and water is bent and warped due to refraction, especially near the edges and bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The cyan background seen through the curved glass and water is bent and warped due to refraction, especially near the edges and bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow appears uniformly dark without bright, focused lines or patterns typical of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow appears uniformly dark without bright, focused lines or patterns typical of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and bending the view of the ball’s lower half, making its shape appear warped compared to the part above the rim.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and bending the view of the ball’s lower half, making its shape appear warped compared to the part above the rim.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid that is in contact with the inner walls, so they are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains liquid that is in contact with the inner walls, so they are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is near the rim, partially above the glass, indicating it’s floating in liquid rather than resting on the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is near the rim, partially above the glass, indicating it’s floating in liquid rather than resting on the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and shifting the cyan areas—especially near the base rim—so it appears distorted rather than undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and shifting the cyan areas—especially near the base rim—so it appears distorted rather than undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "A bright curved highlight within the shadow indicates refracted light caustics from the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"A bright curved highlight within the shadow indicates refracted light caustics from the glass.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water magnifies and shifts the submerged part, making the lower half appear altered in shape and position.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water magnifies and shifts the submerged part, making the lower half appear altered in shape and position.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains water, so the inner surface below the waterline is wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains water, so the inner surface below the waterline is wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating at the water’s surface near the rim, with clear space visible between it and the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating at the water’s surface near the rim, with clear space visible between it and the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract light, causing bending and magnification of the cyan background near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract light, causing bending and magnification of the cyan background near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved streaks are visible along the shadow’s edge, indicating focused light (caustics).",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved streaks are visible along the shadow’s edge, indicating focused light (caustics).\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the view, magnifying and warping the lower half of the ball compared to the upper half outside the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the view, magnifying and warping the lower half of the ball compared to the upper half outside the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "No water droplets or condensation are visible; the glass appears empty and dry inside.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"No water droplets or condensation are visible; the glass appears empty and dry inside.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is positioned near the top of the glass, with empty space below it; it is not touching the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is positioned near the top of the glass, with empty space below it; it is not touching the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light, causing visible warping and shading near the rim, so the cyan background isn’t seen undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light, causing visible warping and shading near the rim, so the cyan background isn’t seen undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights from refracted light appear within the dark shadow area, indicating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights from refracted light appear within the dark shadow area, indicating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the view so the lower half of the tennis ball appears bent/distorted through it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens, refracting and magnifying the view so the lower half of the tennis ball appears bent/distorted through it.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The inner surface looks clear with no droplets, fogging, or liquid film visible.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The inner surface looks clear with no droplets, fogging, or liquid film visible.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The green circular shape is a reflection/refraction from a tennis ball outside the glass (likely beneath it), not a ball sitting inside on the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The green circular shape is a reflection/refraction from a tennis ball outside the glass (likely beneath it), not a ball sitting inside on the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, creating warped areas and bright streaks, so it isn’t seen undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, creating warped areas and bright streaks, so it isn’t seen undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow appears uniformly dark without bright, focused light patterns typical of caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow appears uniformly dark without bright, focused light patterns typical of caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and warping the lower portion of the ball seen through it.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract light, magnifying and warping the lower portion of the ball seen through it.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass is filled with liquid up to the brim, so the inner walls are in contact with the liquid and not dry.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass is filled with liquid up to the brim, so the inner walls are in contact with the liquid and not dry.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is too large and is wedged at the rim, protruding above the glass, so it isn’t touching the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is too large and is wedged at the rim, protruding above the glass, so it isn’t touching the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and altering its appearance rather than showing it clearly.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract the background, bending and altering its appearance rather than showing it clearly.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The shadow shows lighter curved lines and bright patches typical of light focusing through a glass, indicating caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The shadow shows lighter curved lines and bright patches typical of light focusing through a glass, indicating caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Viewing through the curved glass and liquid causes refraction, which geometrically distorts the lower half of the tennis ball.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Viewing through the curved glass and liquid causes refraction, which geometrically distorts the lower half of the tennis ball.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid, so the inner walls are wet up to the fill line.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\": \"No\", \"explanation\": \"The glass contains liquid, so the inner walls are wet up to the fill line.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is only a glass with green liquid; no tennis ball is visible at the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is only a glass with green liquid; no tennis ball is visible at the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and liquid refract the light, causing the cyan background to appear bent and color-shifted, not undistorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and liquid refract the light, causing the cyan background to appear bent and color-shifted, not undistorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved light bands appear within the shadow near the glass, indicating caustics from refracted light.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved light bands appear within the shadow near the glass, indicating caustics from refracted light.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, magnifying and shifting the submerged part, so the lower half appears bulged and misaligned.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water acts like a lens, magnifying and shifting the submerged part, so the lower half appears bulged and misaligned.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains water, so the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating at the water’s surface near the rim, with a visible water gap below it far from the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating at the water’s surface near the rim, with a visible water gap below it far from the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract the light, causing the cyan background to appear shifted and warped near the edges.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract the light, causing the cyan background to appear shifted and warped near the edges.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights within the shadow indicate light focused through the glass, forming caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights within the shadow indicate light focused through the glass, forming caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass acts like a lens; refraction through its cylindrical wall shifts and slightly magnifies the ball’s lower half, making it appear offset and warped.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass acts like a lens; refraction through its cylindrical wall shifts and slightly magnifies the ball’s lower half, making it appear offset and warped.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears empty with no visible liquid, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears empty with no visible liquid, droplets, or condensation on the inner surface.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is near the rim of the glass and suspended above the bottom, not touching the flat base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is near the rim of the glass and suspended above the bottom, not touching the flat base.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The background appears as a uniform cyan color through the cylindrical glass without noticeable bending or warping; only reflections and shadows are present.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The background appears as a uniform cyan color through the cylindrical glass without noticeable bending or warping; only reflections and shadows are present.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights within and along the shadow from the glass indicate refracted, focused light (caustics).",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights within and along the shadow from the glass indicate refracted, focused light (caustics).\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts light like a lens, magnifying and bending the view of the ball’s lower half, making it appear misshapen compared to the upper part seen directly.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts light like a lens, magnifying and bending the view of the ball’s lower half, making it appear misshapen compared to the upper part seen directly.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass appears clear and empty with no visible water droplets or condensation on the inner walls.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The glass appears clear and empty with no visible water droplets or condensation on the inner walls.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is suspended near the top of the glass with visible space between it and the flat bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is suspended near the top of the glass with visible space between it and the flat bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and warping near the edges and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and warping near the edges and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved bands within the glass’s shadow indicate light focusing through the transparent material—caustic streaks.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved bands within the glass’s shadow indicate light focusing through the transparent material—caustic streaks.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts and magnifies the part of the ball seen through it, warping the seam and text so the lower half appears shifted and distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts and magnifies the part of the ball seen through it, warping the seam and text so the lower half appears shifted and distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "Small water droplets are visible on the inner surface of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"Small water droplets are visible on the inner surface of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is suspended near the rim with visible space between it and the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is suspended near the rim with visible space between it and the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and magnification, especially near the edges and base.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass refracts the background, causing visible bending and magnification, especially near the edges and base.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There are bright curved bands within the shadow near the object's edge, indicative of caustic streaks formed by refracted light.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"There are bright curved bands within the shadow near the object's edge, indicative of caustic streaks formed by refracted light.\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": true,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "There is no visible tennis ball in the image, so no geometric distortion can be observed through the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no visible tennis ball in the image, so no geometric distortion can be observed through the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The glass contains liquid touching the sides, indicating the inner walls are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The glass contains liquid touching the sides, indicating the inner walls are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "There is no visible tennis ball in the glass; it appears empty or translucent without any ball at the bottom.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"There is no visible tennis ball in the glass; it appears empty or translucent without any ball at the bottom.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The cyan background appears blurred and color-shifted through the glass and liquid, indicating distortion from opacity and refraction.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The cyan background appears blurred and color-shifted through the glass and liquid, indicating distortion from opacity and refraction.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
[
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Bright curved highlights appear within the dark shadow near the glass, indicating refracted light patterns (caustics).",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Bright curved highlights appear within the dark shadow near the glass, indicating refracted light patterns (caustics).\"}",
"question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "Yes",
"ground_truth_answer": "No",
"model_explanation": "Refraction through the curved glass and water bends and magnifies the view of the submerged half, making it appear warped compared to the part above water.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"Yes\",\"explanation\":\"Refraction through the curved glass and water bends and magnifies the view of the submerged half, making it appear warped compared to the part above water.\"}",
"question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The water inside the glass is in contact with the inner walls below the waterline, so they are wet.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The water inside the glass is in contact with the inner walls below the waterline, so they are wet.\"}",
"question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The ball is floating near the top of the water, partially above the surface, not touching the bottom of the glass.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The ball is floating near the top of the water, partially above the surface, not touching the bottom of the glass.\"}",
"question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?"
},
{
"Correction": false,
"answer": "No",
"ground_truth_answer": "Yes",
"model_explanation": "The curved glass and water refract light, causing visible bending and magnification at the edges and waterline, so the cyan background is distorted.",
"model_response": "{\"answer\":\"No\",\"explanation\":\"The curved glass and water refract light, causing visible bending and magnification at the edges and waterline, so the cyan background is distorted.\"}",
"question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?"
}
] |
|||||||||||||||||
0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the tulips from the scene.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":462.5911330049261,"width":119.4679802955665,"x":692.5911330049261,"y(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e6(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0781_0c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0781_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0781_0c5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0781_0c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673ad(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673a(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e67(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0780_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add5(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0780_Remove_the_tulips_from_the_sce(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is only wate(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip blo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass contai(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip pet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip flo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass appears (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip blo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No tulip or cylind(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A pink tulip flo(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glasses appear(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"You can see tuli(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass contains(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The pink tulip f(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A green tulip st(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c07773
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Refraction
|
remove
|
Remove the glass of water from the image.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":744.4338335607096,"width":507.830832196453,"x":36.70914039447193,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c0(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0785_0f(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0785_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0785_0f4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0785_0f(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc43(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc4(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40b(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0785_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0784_0f44b81d1b761066b2a40bc439c(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0784_Remove_the_glass_of_water_from(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"Only a hand and fa(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No glass or circul(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The hand is empty (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No drinking glass (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No drinking glass (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The object being h(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is only a pe(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No glass or circul(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The top edge of (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the vase with flowers from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":260.5736782902137,"width":317.0697412823397,"x":228.63987044722856,"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1194_1_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/1194_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1194_1_O(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1194_1_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/1193_1_Optics_Reflection_remove_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/1193_Remove_the_vase_with_flowers_f(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A mirrored spher(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A faint circular(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"There is no visibl(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"No reflection of a(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass table su(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tabletop(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
10
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the car from the image.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":256.84113300492606,"width":722.0628078817733,"x":266.7894088669952,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1036_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/1036_Optics_Light_Propagation_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1036_10_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1036_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/1035_10_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/1035_Remove_the_car_from_the_image_(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The highlighted (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The scene shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The region shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The annotated re(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
1000
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
remove
|
Remove the statue of the child holding grapes.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":740.4894671623297,"width":526.5982785831459,"x":156.401721416854,"y"(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Pro(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Pr(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1061_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/1061_Optics_Light_Propagation_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1061_100(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1061_10(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/1060_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/1060_Remove_the_statue_of_the_child(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A shadow of a ch(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows si(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"It shows a marble (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows pa(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows a (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image shows va(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The image only sho(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
11
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the ladder to the left.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":404.69215265866205,"width":506.1653945111491,"x":1.251437202865309,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0989_11(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0989_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0989_11_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0989_11(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0988_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0988_Move_the_ladder_to_the_left_60(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder is pa(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom end o(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"There is no visi(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only part of the(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The bottom ends (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"There is no visi(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image is cro(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only part of the(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only a wall and (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder’s l(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The image is cro(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The ladder’s b(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only the ladder(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"Only part of the(...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
14
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Light_Propagation
|
move
|
Move the glass to the left end of the table.
| [{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":786.0689655172415,"width":390.2068965517242,"x":0.7758620689654546,(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Prop(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0979_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/0979_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0979_14_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/0979_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/0978_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/0978_Move_the_glass_to_the_left_end(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark circula(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"On the tabletop,(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The triangular s(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The elongated sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadows of t(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The light source(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The darker shado(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"There is no glas(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The dark ellipti(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow exten(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The light comes (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The glass’s sh(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","model_explanation":"The shadow from (...TRUNCATED) |
|||||||||||||||||
144
|
superficial
|
Optics
|
Reflection
|
remove
|
Remove the white bowl from the table.
| [{"answer":"No","box":{"height":205.0,"width":175.31034482758622,"x":228.39655172413788,"y":220.5517(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflectio(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1191_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_superficial/output_img/1191_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1191_144(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_superficial_double/output_img/1191_14(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_superficial/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_superficial/output_img/1190_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED) | "results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_superficial/output_img/1190_Remove_the_white_bowl_from_the(...TRUNCATED) |
Processed_N/A
| [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop is (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glass tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A bright curved (...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A mirrored image(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"A light patch on(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop refle(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The shiny tablet(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":true,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The tabletop shows(...TRUNCATED) | [{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","model_explanation":"The glossy table(...TRUNCATED) |
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 20