JackyZhuo/PICABench_score_v1_explicit · Datasets at Hugging Face

'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda

explicit

Mechanics

Causality

remove

Remove the 5 of spades card from the structure.

[ { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 560.9180035650623, "width": 445.8110516934047, "x": 0.11558792796111962, "y": 466.24174810990223 }, "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 1018.9510313336491, "width": 643.1751853303017, "x": 0, "y": 0 }, "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 1017.0630630630632, "width": 683, "x": 0, "y": 3.0913770913770917 }, "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 1017.0630630630632, "width": 683, "x": 0, "y": 3.0913770913770917 }, "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 1017.0630630630632, "width": 683, "x": 0, "y": 3.0913770913770917 }, "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 1017.0630630630632, "width": 683, "x": 0, "y": 3.0913770913770917 }, "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0047_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0047_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0046_'house of cards table' by mauricio arruda_Mechanics_Causality_remove_edited.png

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0046_Remove_the_front-left_vertical_support_cardthe_5_of_spadesfrom_the_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png

Processed_N/A

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The tabletop appears level; it doesn’t tilt toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass top appears level, not tilted toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the glass top appears level, not tilted toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The glass top is supported by the remaining stacks of oversized cards.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The fallen stack has made the tabletop tilt, but the glass is still resting on the remaining card stacks.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It appears level rather than tilted toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass tabletop appears level, not tilted toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The glass top is supported by the intact stacks of cards despite one stack having collapsed.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The tilted glass top is still resting on the remaining stacks of cards.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It only looks tilted because of the perspective and the angled playing-card supports; the glass top is level.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The glass top is still supported by the remaining card stacks despite one card falling.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass tabletop appears level, not tilted toward the front-left corner.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a 5 of spades card present within the annotated region?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the glass tabletop tilted toward the front-left corner?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there an open gap in the front-left bay of the card structure?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there exactly one contiguous playing card lying flat on the floor beneath the lowered front-left corner of the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tilted glass tabletop resting on the remaining card stacks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is there a grounded shadow directly beneath the fallen card at the front-left?" } ]

0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e

explicit

Optics

Refraction

remove

Remove the water from the glass cup.

[ { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 235.39035597238362, "width": 180.6764455574513, "x": 0, "y": 651.0579198896858 }, "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 705.8482866160331, "width": 525.204276946535, "x": 85.603448275862, "y": 156.93103448275863 }, "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 731.0270270270271, "width": 593.2972972972973, "x": 1.7162162162161916, "y": 172.54054054054055 }, "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 731.0270270270271, "width": 593.2972972972973, "x": 1.7162162162161916, "y": 172.54054054054055 }, "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 731.0270270270271, "width": 593.2972972972973, "x": 1.7162162162161916, "y": 172.54054054054055 }, "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0804_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0804_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0803_0a3797ae05224b11c2d22eda227d376e_Optics_Refraction_remove_edited.png

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0803_In_the_photo_of_a_clear_glass_tumbler_on_a_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png

Processed_N/A

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The glass’s curved, thick bottom refracts the light, so the lower half of the ball appears compressed/magnified—i.e., geometrically distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes, they appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass has a domed/curved inner bottom, so the tennis ball is sitting on that raised curve rather than on a flat bottom surface.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The cyan background appears slightly warped through the curved glass due to refraction.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved glass and water refract light, so the submerged lower half appears magnified and slightly shifted, creating geometric distortion.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—they appear wet, with visible streaks/droplets on the inside.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is floating slightly above the bottom—there’s water in the glass, and you can see a gap/shadow and refraction around the ball.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The cyan background appears warped through the curved glass walls due to refraction, so it’s not undistorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved glass (and water, if present) refracts light, so the lower half of the ball appears shifted and slightly magnified—an optical distortion rather than its true geometry.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes—the inner walls look dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is stuck near the rim of the glass, not resting on the flat bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass refracts the light, so the cyan background appears warped and slightly shifted, not undistorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The submerged half is viewed through curved glass and water, so refraction at those interfaces distorts it—shifting it upward and altering its apparent size/shape (squashed vertically and slightly magnified laterally).", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The inner walls show visible droplets/residue, so they’re wet.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It’s floating at the surface; refraction through the water and glass makes it look like it’s at the bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass and water refract the light, so the cyan background appears warped/distorted through the walls.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved glass refracts the light, so the lower half of the ball appears warped/magnified compared to the part above the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes, the inner walls appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No, it appears distorted through the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved glass (and the liquid) refracts light, acting like a cylindrical lens. That changes magnification and bends rays, so the lower half of the ball seen through the glass appears shifted and warped relative to the upper half.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The inner walls above the liquid appear dry—no droplets or condensation are visible.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball isn’t in the glass at all—it’s behind it. The matching color and refraction in the liquid make it look like it’s inside, but it couldn’t fit through the rim.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass (and liquid) refracts the light, so the cyan background appears warped near the edges.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Through the (nearly) parallel walls of the glass and water, the light rays are bent but emerge parallel to their original direction, causing mainly a lateral shift and brightness change, not a stretch or squeeze. So the lower half isn’t geometrically distorted; it just looks slightly displaced.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The inner walls are wet where they’re in contact with the water; only the area above the waterline is dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is floating at the water’s surface; the green shape at the bottom is just a refracted/reflected image, not the ball resting on the flat bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the curved glass and water refract the view, so the cyan background appears distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "The ball itself isn’t distorted, but its image is. The curved, thick glass refracts the light, causing optical distortion (magnification and displacement) of the lower half when viewed through the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The inner walls look clear with no droplets or streaks—just reflections—so they appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass has a thick base with a raised inner dome, so the tennis ball sits on that curved bump, not on the flat outer bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The cyan background appears warped and shifted through the glass due to refraction and reflections, not undistorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved wall of the glass acts like a lens, refracting the light from the ball and making the lower half appear slightly magnified and warped.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes—the inner walls look dry, with no visible moisture or droplets.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It’s supported by the curved inner bottom/walls of the glass, not a flat base.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—it's visibly distorted by the curved glass and refraction, especially near the edges.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved glass and water refract light, so the lower half of the ball appears shifted and magnified compared to the part above the water.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the inner walls in contact with the water are wet.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The tennis ball is floating on the water, not resting on the bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The cyan background appears distorted through the curved glass and water due to refraction.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The lower half looks compressed/magnified because the curved glass (and any water) refracts light like a lens, distorting the image of the ball. The ball itself isn’t deformed—only its appearance through the glass is.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No — the inner walls look wet with moisture/droplets.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass has a raised/convex base, so the ball isn’t on a flat bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The cyan background appears distorted through the curved glass due to refraction.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The lower half looks warped due to refraction through the curved, thicker bottom of the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The inner walls appear dry with no visible moisture or condensation.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is suspended above the bottom, not resting on it.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass walls refract the cyan background, causing visible distortion near the edges.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved wall of the glass acts like a cylindrical lens, so refraction bends the light from the lower half of the ball and makes it appear shifted/magnified—i.e., geometrically distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes, the inner walls appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is suspended above the bottom of the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass refracts the light, so the cyan background appears slightly warped.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The glass wall has (nearly) parallel inner and outer surfaces, so the refraction as light enters and then exits cancels out. That preserves the geometry of what you see through it—only a small lateral shift or brightness change may occur, not a shape distortion.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The inner walls appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The ball is suspended above the bottom; the bright circle at the base is just its reflection/refraction, not the ball resting on the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass refracts the view, so the cyan background appears slightly distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved, thick bottom of the glass acts like a lens, refracting light and altering magnification, so the lower half of the ball appears geometrically distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes, they appear dry.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass has a raised/curved inner base, and the tennis ball is resting on that dome, not on a flat bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass causes refraction and reflections, so the cyan background looks slightly warped, especially near the edges.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the shadow contain caustic streaks?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The curved, thick bottom of the glass refracts the view, making the lower half of the tennis ball appear slightly magnified and distorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is the lower half of the tennis ball geometrically distorted when viewed through the glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The inner walls appear dry—no visible water, droplets, or condensation.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Are the inner walls of the glass dry?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It’s sitting on the raised, curved inner base of the glass, not the flat bottom.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the tennis ball resting on the flat bottom of the glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The curved glass refracts and reflects the light, so the cyan background appears warped and shifted rather than undistorted.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the cyan background visible through the glass walls undistorted?" } ]

0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a

explicit

Optics

Refraction

remove

Remove the tulips from the scene.

[ { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 462.5911330049261, "width": 119.4679802955665, "x": 692.5911330049261, "y": 462.5911330049261 }, "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 231.99014778325125, "width": 219.48768472906406, "x": 210.55172413793102, "y": 683.4679802955665 }, "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 140.30541871921181, "width": 119.4679802955665, "x": 842.6206896551724, "y": 766.8177339901478 }, "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 184.97247491500931, "width": 123.66070375082258, "x": 59.95331739763949, "y": 717.4824730781288 }, "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 461.0849652668569, "width": 1020.2066389076709, "x": 0.08998346689579502, "y": 560.3992595878841 }, "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 368.2574289181624, "width": 142.84090822748743, "x": 467.7896336444337, "y": 558.3139996532663 }, "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 320.5808180313657, "width": 107.78627157380406, "x": 589.0725398545686, "y": 558.0839726670482 }, "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 888.4324324324325, "width": 897.5135135135135, "x": 55.67567567567566, "y": 40.86486486486486 }, "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 888.4324324324325, "width": 897.5135135135135, "x": 55.67567567567566, "y": 40.86486486486486 }, "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 888.4324324324325, "width": 897.5135135135135, "x": 55.67567567567566, "y": 40.86486486486486 }, "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 888.4324324324325, "width": 897.5135135135135, "x": 55.67567567567566, "y": 40.86486486486486 }, "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 888.4324324324325, "width": 897.5135135135135, "x": 55.67567567567566, "y": 40.86486486486486 }, "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0781_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0781_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0780_0c5d96e6740444b32e1e673add56f02a_Optics_Refraction_remove_edited.png

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0780_Remove_every_part_of_the_tulips_from_the_sceneflowers_stems_512x512_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png

Processed_N/A

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The tulip’s stem is inside the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the glass contours appear smooth and continuous without breaks.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There are no plant parts visible inside the glass vessels.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The highlights are neutral/white, not tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There are no tulip cast shadows on the tabletop.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water levels look calm and show visible concave menisci along the glass rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There is no tulip stem visible inside the vase.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white, not showing any tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces show slight, settled menisci at the rims where the liquid meets the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There isn’t a tulip blossom on the tabletop.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There are no plant parts in the glass vessels.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The highlights are neutral/white, not tulip-colored.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces curve up slightly at the glass edges, showing settled (concave) menisci at the rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The tulip’s stem/leaves are inside the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The outer edges of the glass objects form smooth, unbroken silhouettes—the contours are continuous, even though highlights/refractions vary inside them.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only some of the vessels show plant parts; others appear empty.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The highlights are neutral/white; they don’t show tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces show slight concave menisci at the rims, consistent with water in glass after settling.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The tulip’s stem is inside the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the outlines of the glass objects appear smooth and continuous without breaks.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only one of the vessels contains plant stems; the others appear to just have water or are empty.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights look neutral/white, not tinted with the tulip’s colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces look calm and show slight menisci along the glass rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the glass objects have smooth, continuous contours.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There are no plant parts inside the glass vessels.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The highlights are neutral/white, not showing tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes — the water surfaces show settled (concave) menisci at the rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white, not tinted with tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the outlines of the glassware appear smooth and continuous without breaks.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white, not colored by the tulips.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There is no visible tulip inside the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There is no tulip inside the glass sphere.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The glass vessels appear empty; there are no plant parts inside them.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white; there are no tulip colors reflected.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces show slight concave menisci at the rims of the glasses.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. A tulip flower is inside the tall cylindrical glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No—the contours appear broken/discontinuous due to refraction and reflections in the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are bright white; the tulip colors appear in the refracted/reflected areas, not in the highlights.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water in the glass vessels shows curved surfaces at the edges, clinging to the glass—indicative of settled menisci.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes, the glass contours appear continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Some of the glass vessels are empty.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white; they don’t show tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water in the glasses appears still, showing smooth, settled menisci at the rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There isn’t a tulip blossom on the tabletop.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only the green stems/leaves are visible in the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the glass outlines appear smooth and unbroken, with continuous contours.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only some vessels contain plant stems; others are empty or just have water.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white, not tinted by the tulips’ colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The water surfaces appear perfectly flat with no visible meniscus at the rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the outlines of the glass objects appear smooth and continuous without visible breaks.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only some of the glasses show plant parts; others are empty/clear.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white; they don’t show any tulip colors.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces look calm, and you can see slight concave menisci along the rims of the glasses.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The tulip you see is just a distorted view/reflection through the glass; no part of it is inside.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. There are no plant parts visible inside the glass vessels.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white, not tulip-colored.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces show settled menisci at the rims.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. It’s just a reflection or shadow that looks like a tulip, not an actual flower inside the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—the glass outlines appear smooth and continuous without breaks.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only some vessels show plant parts as reflections/shadows; not every vessel has them.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The specular highlights are neutral/white; they don’t show any tulip colors—only light reflections and silhouettes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water shows slight concave menisci at the rims of the glasses.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "I can’t tell—there’s no visible glass sphere or tulip in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any part of a tulip inside the round glass sphere?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip inside the small shot glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip plant material inside the short glass?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a tulip blossom on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is any tulip stem visible inside the clear cylindrical vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a tulip visible inside the cylindrical glass?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The outlines of the glasses appear smooth and unbroken.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are the glass contours continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Only one of the glasses appears to contain a plant part; the others do not.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are plant parts present inside every glass vessel?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—there are faint reflections of tulip colors (reds and greens) in the highlights on the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do the specular highlights on the glass surfaces show tulip colors?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Are tulip cast shadows present on the tabletop?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The water surfaces show slight concave menisci at the rims of the glasses.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Do the water surfaces have settled menisci at their rims?" } ]

1

explicit

Optics

Reflection

remove

Remove the vase with flowers from the table.

[ { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 260.5736782902137, "width": 317.0697412823397, "x": 228.63987044722856, "y": 420.2750475156122 }, "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 401.1258611997982, "width": 326.29810115946884, "x": 189.8756548814221, "y": 113.23453955118322 }, "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 521.0038610038611, "width": 283.0888030888031, "x": 209.7432432432432, "y": 137.02702702702703 }, "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 521.0038610038611, "width": 283.0888030888031, "x": 209.7432432432432, "y": 137.02702702702703 }, "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1194_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1194_1_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1193_1_Optics_Reflection_remove_edited.png

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1193_Erase_the_round_ribbed_clear_glass_vase_filled_with_small_608x416_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png

Processed_N/A

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. The glass appears to be a single, continuous sheet over the frame.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The sofa and pillows have different fabrics/textures, so the pattern isn’t continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the glass top is divided into separate panes by the metal grid, so it isn’t continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass is segmented into panels by the frame, not one continuous surface.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The sofa and pillows have different fabrics/patterns.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. I don’t see a round clear glass vase in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes—the top glass surface appears to be one continuous sheet, with the grid you see underneath the glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The sofa fabric and the pillows have different textures/patterns.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. I don’t see a round clear glass vase in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The tabletop is divided into separate glass panels by the frame, not one continuous surface.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The sofa and pillows have different fabrics/textures, so the pattern isn’t continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The tabletop is divided into sections by the frame, not one continuous glass surface.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows have different fabrics, so the pattern isn’t continuous with the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No — it’s segmented into separate glass panels divided by the metal frame.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows are different fabric/colors, so the pattern does not continue across them and the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the tabletop surface is segmented into multiple glass panels separated by the frame, not a single continuous sheet.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows have different textures/patterns from the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. I don’t see a round clear glass vase in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the top glass surface is segmented into sections by the frame, not a single continuous pane.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows use different fabrics, so the pattern isn’t continuous with the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the top glass surface is split by the frame; it isn’t one continuous piece.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pattern on the pillows doesn’t line up seamlessly with the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The glass top is divided into separate panels, not one continuous sheet.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. There’s no visible continuous pattern; the fabrics look plain/solid.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows have a different fabric/color, so the pattern isn’t continuous with the sofa.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. I don’t see a round clear glass vase in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the tabletop is divided into separate glass panels by the frame, not one continuous surface.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The sofa and pillows have different textures/patterns.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes. It appears to be a single, continuous glass surface with a grid frame visible beneath it.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. It’s segmented into separate glass panels within the metal frame, not one continuous piece.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows have different fabrics/textures from the sofa, so the pattern isn’t continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Does the table surface contain a reflection of the round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. I don’t see a round clear glass vase in the image.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is there a round clear glass vase?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the tabletop is divided into sections by the frame, not one continuous piece of glass.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the top glass tabletop surface continuous?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The pillows have different textures from the sofa, so the pattern isn’t continuous.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Is the upholstery pattern continuous across the sofa and pillows?" } ]

10

explicit

Optics

Light_Propagation

remove

Remove the car from the image.

[ { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 256.84113300492606, "width": 722.0628078817733, "x": 266.7894088669952, "y": 190.9347290640394 }, "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 415.0841204277821, "width": 1021.3683215799144, "x": 2.190723357448906, "y": 269.5144282077817 }, "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "answer": "No", "box": { "height": 97.89039408866992, "width": 716.2475369458127, "x": 290.2306116221285, "y": 365.7530951654387 }, "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "answer": "Yes", "box": { "height": 253.92020592020592, "width": 715.4954954954954, "x": 275.8326898326898, "y": 196.8957528957529 }, "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1036_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1036_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove.jpg

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1035_10_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove_edited.png

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1035_Erase_the_entire_red_vintage_convertible_and_its_driver_from_416x608_t64_cfg2.5_cfgimg4.0_edit_remove.png

Processed_N/A

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Short answer: it depends on what you call “shadow.”\n\n- If shadow means any dimming (penumbra), then yes: the set of points on the road that get less light because of the tree is a single connected band. A tree is connected, and the projection of a connected object (sunlight is essentially a set of parallel rays) is connected, though it can contain many holes and varying darkness.\n\n- If shadow means full blockage (umbra), then no: the umbra of a leafy tree breaks into many small, separated patches where individual leaves fully cover the sun’s disk.\n\nSo the mottled shade you see across a road is one continuous band of penumbra with lots of bright “holes,” not a continuous band of umbra.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled section is a different tone than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Shadows from tree branches and leaves are dappled and broken, with many light gaps and soft penumbras. They don’t create a single continuous, uniform band; that would require a long, continuous object (e.g., a curb or rail) casting the shadow.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled area is much darker than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Tree-branch shadows are dappled and irregular; they break up and vary in intensity rather than forming a continuous band.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled area is a different tone than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled strip is a different tone—warmer and lighter—than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. The shadow from tree branches is usually a dappled pattern of overlapping light and dark patches. It only looks like a continuous band if the canopy is very dense or if you average over time (e.g., wind-blown leaves blur the pattern), but at any instant it isn’t a single continuous shadow.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled section is darker than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the filled section is darker than the surrounding asphalt, so it doesn’t match.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the filled section is a different tone than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The tree-branch shadows align to form one continuous diagonal band.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled section is a noticeably different tone than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes—at a distance, the many penumbras from thousands of leaves/branches overlap and their “envelope” looks like a continuous dark band. It isn’t a single sharp, fully dark shadow, but a region of reduced illumination made from many overlapping, mottled shadows that blur together.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled patch is noticeably darker than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": false, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "- At any instant: No. The shadow from branches is a web with sunlit gaps, not a single continuous band.\n- Over time (with wind motion or as the sun moves): The shadows sweep through many positions and the time-averaged or long‑exposure result becomes an approximately continuous band bounded by the canopy’s outer silhouette.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No. Tree-branch shadows are dappled—patchy bits of shade and sun—so they don’t make a continuous band unless the foliage is essentially solid.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the filled section is noticeably darker than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes. The tree-branch shadows merge to form a continuous dark band across the road.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No—the filled section is noticeably lighter than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled patch is a different tone than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No — the filled patch is lighter and doesn’t match the tone of the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Usually no. Sunlight comes from an extended disk, and the gaps between leaves/branches act like many small pinholes that project soft, overlapping images of the Sun. That creates a dappled mix of umbra/penumbra rather than a single continuous dark band. It can look nearly continuous only if the canopy is very dense or the Sun is very low/diffuse (e.g., overcast).", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No.", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

[ { "Correction": true, "answer": "Yes", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the annotated region contain exactly zero car instances?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Do tree-branch shadows form a continuous band?" }, { "Correction": true, "answer": "No", "ground_truth_answer": "No", "question": "Is a shadow cast by a car present?" }, { "Correction": false, "answer": "No. The filled section is darker than the surrounding asphalt.", "ground_truth_answer": "Yes", "question": "Does the filled road surface match the tone of the surrounding asphalt?" } ]

1000

explicit

Optics

Light_Propagation

remove

Remove the statue of the child holding grapes.

[{"answer":"No","box":{"height":740.4894671623297,"width":526.5982785831459,"x":156.401721416854,"y"(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propag(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propa(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_r(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1061_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_O(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1061_1000_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1061_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1060_1000_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1060_Delete_the_entire_rightforeground(...TRUNCATED)

Processed_N/A

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of a (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No. There’s no marble statue visible in the image.","ground_truth_an(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of a (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of a (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the marble statue of a (...TRUNCATED)

11

explicit

Optics

Light_Propagation

move

Move the ladder to the left.

[{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":404.69215265866205,"width":506.1653945111491,"x":1.251437202865309,(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0989_Optics_Light_Propagation_move.j(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Opt(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0989_11_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0989_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0988_11_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0988_Translate_the_weathered_wooden_la(...TRUNCATED)

Processed_N/A

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leanin(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No. The base is out of the frame.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","quest(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leanin(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the base of the leani(...TRUNCATED)

14

explicit

Optics

Light_Propagation

move

Move the glass to the left end of the table.

[{"answer":"Yes","box":{"height":786.0689655172415,"width":390.2068965517242,"x":0.7758620689654546,(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mov(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/0979_Optics_Light_Propagation_move.j(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Opt(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/0979_14_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/0979_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/0978_14_Optics_Light_Propagation_mo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/0978_Relocate_the_clear_round_glass_on(...TRUNCATED)

Processed_N/A

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the glass's shadow ca(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No. The shadow falls toward the upper-left, not the lower-right.","gr(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the glass's shadow ca(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the glass's shadow ca(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"Yes","question":"Is the glass's shadow ca(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"No. The shadow falls toward the lower-left.","ground_truth_answer":"Y(...TRUNCATED)

144

explicit

Optics

Reflection

remove

Remove the white bowl from the table.

[{"answer":"No","box":{"height":205.0,"width":175.31034482758622,"x":228.39655172413788,"y":220.5517(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_re(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_r(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.jp(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_O(...TRUNCATED)

results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1191_Optics_Reflection_remove.jpg

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remo(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1191_144_O(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remov(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_rem(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1191_144_Optics_Reflection_remove.j(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1190_144_Optics_Reflection_remove_e(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1190_Remove_the_white_ceramic_bowl_pos(...TRUNCATED)

Processed_N/A

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the w(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the w(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the (...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is the reflection of the (...TRUNCATED)

15

explicit

Optics

Light_Propagation

remove

Remove the statue of Buddha.

[{"answer":"No","box":{"height":850.7215936833543,"width":323.29617430960224,"x":283.75686403965886,(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Seedream_Edits_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagat(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_GPT_Image_Edits_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propaga(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_Gemini_Edits_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_qwenimg_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagation_rem(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_12k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1025_15_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_ovis_u1_explicit/output_img/1025_Optics_Light_Propagation_remove(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_005_kontext_8k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1025_15_Opt(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_flux_kontext_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagatio(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_009_kontext_10k_lora256ema_explicit_double/output_img/1025_15_Op(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_hidream_e1_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagation_(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_stepedit_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_think_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagation(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_bagel_nothink_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagati(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_omnigen2_explicit/output_img/1025_15_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_uniworld_explicit/output_img/1024_15_Optics_Light_Propagation_re(...TRUNCATED)

"results/PhysEdit_results/PICABench_DIMOO_explicit/output_img/1024_Remove_the_entire_golden_standing(...TRUNCATED)

Processed_N/A

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is a standing golden Buddh(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":false,"answer":"Yes.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is a standing golden Bud(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is a standing golden Buddh(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No. The niche appears empty; there is no standing golden Buddha statue(...TRUNCATED)

[{"Correction":true,"answer":"No.","ground_truth_answer":"No","question":"Is a standing golden Buddh(...TRUNCATED)